DUANE
Get the App
Duane's take
Here's how the official marker tells it, and I'll let those words do the heavy liftin'. Sutton County was barely out of the box, organized in 1890, and already the commissioners knew exactly what kind of town they were buildin'. You don't set up shop on the Texas frontier and assume everybody's gonna behave.
So without much dithering, they went all the way to St. Louis, Missouri, and contracted with the Pauley Jail Building and Manufacturing Company to come down and put something serious in the ground. Construction started in February of 1891, under the watchful eye of Judge J.
L. Dunagan. Now, you build a jail under a judge's supervision, you can bet the workmanship is going to be thorough.
The Pauley crew didn't cut corners; they cut native stone. Two stories of it. And when they were done in September of 1891, what stood there wasn't just a cage.
It had cells for lawbreakers, sure, but it also had a proper jailer's residence right there in the building. Somebody had to keep the lights on, after all. Seven months from first stone to finished building.
And then came the question every new jail eventually has to answer: who's gonna be first? The answer walked right in wearing the name John Denson, gambler, gunman, and as it happens, a cousin of outlaw John Wesley Hardin. Of all the people in West Texas to inaugurate your brand-new lockup, Sutton County got a man with that particular family tree.
Some buildings take years to find their story. This one didn't have to wait long at all.
What the marker says
Soon after Sutton County was organized (1890), the commissioners authorized the Pauley Jail Building and Manufacturing Co. of St. Louis to erect this jail. Construction was begun in Feb. 1891 under the supervision of Judge J. L. Dunagan. Completed in Sept. 1891, the two story native stone building had a jailer's residence in addition to cells for lawbreakers. The first prisoner here was gambler and gunman John Denson, a cousin of outlaw John Wesley Hardin. Recorded Texas Historic Landmark-1975